main logo 2

Blog

Facebook Retargeting Isn't Working Like It Used To—What Comes Next

1. IOS 14 Update

Introduction

Facebook retargeting was once a mainstay of digital marketing strategy—celebrated for its power to reawaken interest and push conversions by delivering targeted ads to users already familiar with a brand. But in today’s privacy-first, data-constrained world, its efficacy has suffered. From sagging conversion rates to algorithmic deprioritization and increasing costs, the old retargeting playbook is being rewritten in real time.

This article takes a close examination of what’s behind Facebook retargeting’s declining performance, the wider implications for marketers, and how the digital landscape is responding.

The Golden Age of Retargeting

2. Facebook Retargeting

During the pre-privacy-regulation days, retargeting was the ultimate performance strategy. Brands used Facebook Pixel to monitor user behavior—what browsed, what abandoned cart, who lingered on a product page—and then retargeted them highly customized ads. 

The numbers were astounding. A 2017 benchmark indicated that retargeted ads could have 5–10x the conversion rate of cold prospecting ads. Marketers doubled down: by 2019, surveys were reporting that more than 80% of digital advertisers were actively using retargeting, frequently naming it as their number one contributor to ROAS. 

Its success was based on one thing: data. The more specific the behavior being recorded, the more targeted the messaging. That level of specificity is now less attainable. 

Privacy Regulations Shift the Ground

The initial significant disruption did not arise from platforms but from policymakers. GDPR in the EU and CCPA in California imposed new restrictions on data use. But the tipping point came with Apple’s App Tracking Transparency (ATT) launch in 2021. 

Post-ATT, as many as 70% of iOS users avoided app tracking. Advertisers quickly realized their retargeting efficiency took a dramatic dip. Reports within the industry cited a 30–40% decline in Facebook retargeting conversion rates for iOS audiences. The decline wasn’t anecdotal—it was quantified in ad dollars lost and performance metrics sacrificed. 

With fewer signals that flowed back into Meta, there was less to work with by algorithms. Precise targeting which previously characterized retargeting, was replaced with wider, generalized audience segments.

The Birth of Ad Fatigue

Meanwhile, ad numbers exploded even while data pipelines collapsed. In present-day oversaturated digital landscape, users are continually bombarded daily with ads-many of them brands they’ve come across before. This has cultivated ad fatigue that’s increasingly keeping marketers up at night.

Retargeting, by definition, is a repeat message. But in an environment saturated with noise, repetition does not equal relevance. Research has indicated click-through rates on retargeted ads can decrease by 20% or more when frequency is high. By 2022, more than 60% of marketers surveyed reported significant decreases in retargeting engagement.

The problem is two-fold: a decreasing number of trackable users and a decreasing tolerance among those still reachable.

The Decline of Data Granularity

3. Why Facebook Retargeting is Underperforming

Retargeting’s effectiveness always relied on the richness of data. When everyone knew precisely what product an individual looked at, how long they watched it for, and where in the funnel they dropped off from, they could craft razor-sharp messaging. 

Now, that precision has diminished. Studies indicate that the volume of usable behavioral data for retargeting has dropped by almost 50% since iOS14 was introduced. This degradation of accuracy compels campaigns to fall back on general assumptions, watering down relevance and performance. 

Instead of intent-based remarketing, advertisers are left with inferred behavior—a weaker signal in a system that previously flourished on specificity. 

Higher Costs, Lower Returns

As retargeting has lost its potency, it has also grown in cost. Bidding wars over scarce segments of audiences have caused CPMs and CPAs to skyrocket. Some studies show a 25–50% increase in acquisition costs for retargeting campaigns since 2021.

At the same time, Facebook’s changing algorithms—and emphasis on engagement with content—have moved visibility away from more traditional ad locations. Retargeted ads now compete not only with other brands but also with content that is deemed more engaging by the platform and more likely to keep people scrolling.

Both of these forces—increased costs and declining visibility—have many advertisers questioning the ROI of retargeting as a staple strategy.

Strategic Repercussions

These changes aren’t tactical—they’re existential. Companies can no longer approach Facebook retargeting as a reliable, discrete growth driver. It has to work as one piece in a more nuanced, privacy-focused media puzzle.

The economics are obvious: increased ad spend no longer equals results. Advertisers have reacted by shifting some of their retargeting budgets to mid-funnel content, organic list building, and upper-funnel brand storytelling. Performance objectives have moved away from short-term conversion to long-term relationship building.

Toward a Privacy-Resilient Model

A structural reaction to the decline in retargeting is emerging. Top marketers are making investments that circumvent third-party data dependency. These involve:

  1. Server-Side Tracking: Solutions such as Meta’s Conversions API pass data directly between servers, giving advertisers visibility without having to use browser-based tracking.
  2. Contextual Targeting: Advertisers have moved away from following user activity, instead targeting content environments—showing ads based on what the user is seeing and not who the user is.
  3. First-Party Data Collection: Opt-in channels like newsletters, loyalty programs, and gated content are emerging as a basis for recreating data pipes in a world focused on privacy.

These are a fundamental move—a shift away from targeting the person and into creating systems that continue to perform well even when there is no granular personal data.

Diversification and the End of Dependence

In this new world, creative excellence is more crucial than ever. User-generated content (UGC), dynamic ads, and real-time customization are becoming the primary weapons against ad fatigue and improving engagement.

Those using UGC for retargeting have seen up to 4x greater engagement rates, while dynamic creative optimization (DCO) platforms enable more responsive content delivery—even in data-constrained scenarios. 

This change prioritizes relevance over repetition, and storytelling over targeting. 

Creative Innovation as a New Differentiator

Meta’s increasing lead prices aren’t just a line item in the budget—they’re a warning sign. A warning sign that the days of low-cost, predictable, algorithmic lead generation are over. What’s coming is a more dynamic and unpredictable landscape, where attention is costly, quality matters, and marketing resilience is the new currency.

This isn’t a crisis—it’s a recalibration. The brands that come out stronger will be those that know not only how much they’re spending, but what they’re spending it for.

Conclusion

Facebook retargeting isn’t so hot these days—and that’s not always a crisis. It’s a warning. A warning that the fundamentals of digital marketing are changing to a more privacy-aware, more creatively challenging, and more strategically nuanced model.

Slumping conversion rates, increasing costs, diminishing tracking fidelity, and expanding user fatigue all tell the same truth: the playbook is evolving.

Advertisers who get these forces are already adjusting. They’re creating first-party data ecosystems, mixing channel portfolios, and reconsidering the role of retargeting within a more comprehensive customer journey.

This isn’t about leaving behind the tools of the past—but about learning to wield them differently, in an environment where attention is expensive and trust is the real currency.

Recent Posts
AgileSpace Digital
Services
Teams
Resources
Partners
Work
Careers
About Us
whitelogo
Services
Teams
Resources
Partners
Work
Careers
About Us

Privacy Policy      

Linkedin Youtube-square Facebook-square Pinterest-square

© 2025 AgileSpace Digital